How to Find the Epidural Space

The physician recognizes entry into the epidural space when the needle passes the ligamentum flavum and an endpoint appears. The most widely used method today is loss of resistance (LOR): resistance at the plunger disappears when the tip enters the space. The other classical method is the hanging drop technique. Balloon indicators, spring-loaded syringes and computerized pressure measurement make this moment visible.

Epidural space is also called the extradural or peridural space.

Prepared for anesthesiologists, pain physicians, residents and operating room teams.

Basics

Why is accurate identification of the epidural space important?

Difficulty and errors in identifying the epidural space are associated with failure to identify the space, intravascular or subarachnoid catheter placement, accidental dural puncture and block failure.

Studies comparing identification methods most often measure these outcomes (Carvalho 2017; Fyneface-Ogan 2008).

With a midline approach, the Tuohy needle passes through the skin and subcutaneous tissue, then the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments; its tip is seated in the ligamentum flavum. The epidural space lies immediately beyond the ligamentum flavum, with the dura beyond it.

Classical methods

What is the epidural hanging drop technique, and how is it performed?

In the hanging drop technique, a drop placed at the needle hub is drawn into the needle as the tip enters the epidural space; the physician recognizes entry from this sign.

Argentine physician Alberto Gutiérrez described the technique in 1933; it is also known as the Gutiérrez sign (Todorov 2014; Waurick 2015). Italian physician Dogliotti developed the loss of resistance technique around the same time (Waurick 2015). These are the two classical methods used today.

Cross-section of the hanging drop technique. From top to bottom: skin, subcutaneous tissue, supraspinous ligament, interspinous ligament, ligamentum flavum, epidural space and dura. On the left, the curved tip of a Tuohy needle is in the ligamentum flavum, with a drop suspended at the hub. On the right, the tip has entered the epidural space and the drop has been drawn into the needle. drop suspended drop drawn in skin subcutaneous tissue supraspinous ligament interspinous ligament ligamentum flavum epidural space dura
  1. The Tuohy needle is passed through the skin, subcutaneous tissue, and the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments; its tip is seated in the ligamentum flavum.
  2. The stylet is withdrawn. A drop of saline is placed at the needle hub, where it remains suspended.
  3. The physician advances the needle slowly with both hands, watching the drop.
  4. As soon as the tip enters the epidural space, the drop is drawn into the needle. This indicates entry into the space.

Why does it work?

The method relies on pressure at the needle tip falling below atmospheric pressure (becoming negative) when the tip enters the epidural space. Some of this negative pressure comes from the space itself and some from the needle's effect on the tissues (Todorov 2014).

The stated advantages are a visible endpoint, both hands remaining on the needle, and no need for additional equipment.

Does the hanging drop technique work in every patient?

It does not work in every patient: negative pressure is not present in every region or in every position. Measurements provide the strongest support for the technique in the sitting position for thoracic epidurals (Todorov 2014).

  • Thoracic region. In a T5-T6 study, measurements were taken in 28 patients: 14 sitting and 14 in the lateral decubitus position. All pressures were negative in the sitting group (median -5 mmHg); the median was +5 mmHg in the lateral decubitus group (Gil 2008). This finding supports performing the thoracic hanging drop technique with the patient sitting.
  • Cervical region. All pressures were positive in the prone position; they were not consistently negative in the sitting position either. The investigators did not consider the technique suitable for the cervical region (Moon 2010).
  • Lumbar region. No negative pressure was measured while the needle was stationary. Negative pressure observed at the moment of entry is explained as an effect of the needle passing through the ligamentum flavum and pushing the dura (Fukushige 1995; Todorov 2014).
  • Obstetrics. Most labor epidurals are performed at the lumbar level, and epidural pressure increases as labor progresses. The review suggests that the hanging drop technique is not expected to offer an advantage over loss of resistance in the lumbar region (Todorov 2014).

How often is it used?

A review examined controlled cervical and thoracic epidural studies published over the preceding 10 years. Of studies where the technique could be identified, 28.8% used the hanging drop technique, alone or with LOR. Accounting for possible bias, the proportion could be as low as 11.7% (Todorov 2014). In a Spanish survey answered by 617 anesthesiologists, 2.4% had learned the hanging drop technique during residency (Figueredo 2005).

Variants

  • Running drip. A saline set is connected to the needle; saline begins to flow when the epidural space is entered. The method has also been compared with the hanging drop technique in dogs (Martinez-Taboada 2017).
  • Modified hanging drop with a stopcock. A three-way stopcock is attached to the needle hub (Oleas Vivar 2013).

How is the epidural loss of resistance (LOR) technique performed?

The plunger of a syringe attached to the epidural needle is pressed continuously or intermittently; when the tip enters the epidural space, resistance is lost and the plunger moves freely.

Loss of resistance (LOR) is the most widely used method today (Todorov 2014; Kartal 2017). It has three forms, depending on what is placed in the syringe:

  • Saline. In a United Kingdom survey of members of the Obstetric Anaesthetists' Association, 52.7% used saline alone (Howell 1998).
  • Air. The same principle, with air in the syringe. In the Spanish survey, 59.2% used LOR with air (Figueredo 2005).
  • Saline with an air bubble. A small air bubble is present in the saline; compression of the bubble indicates resistance. In the Spanish survey, 6% used this form (Figueredo 2005).

Is there a difference between air and saline?

The Cochrane review found no difference in success or complications between air and saline; the evidence was of low certainty. Most results came from obstetric patients (Antibas 2014).

Newer methods

Which methods show the endpoint visually or on a screen?

Balloon indicators, spring-loaded LOR syringes and computerized pressure measurement systems make the loss of resistance that is felt by hand visible to the eye or on a screen.

  • Balloon indicator. The balloon is inflated and attached to the needle; it deflates when the tip enters the epidural space.
  • Spring-loaded LOR syringe. A spring applies continuous pressure to the plunger; the plunger advances on its own when the tip enters the space.
  • Computerized pressure measurement system. A computerized pump displays and signals the pressure at the needle tip. It is used in difficult cases, training and pain clinics (Capogna 2018; Carassiti 2022).
  1. 01The Tuohy needle is passed through the skin, the subcutaneous tissue, and the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments. Its tip is seated in the ligamentum flavum.

  2. 02The balloon indicator is connected to the needle, and the balloon is inflated.

  3. 03The physician advances the needle slowly.

  4. 04When the tip enters the epidural space the resistance is lost and the balloon deflates.

What does the evidence show?

A meta-analysis combining eight randomized controlled trials (1,583 patients) compared less commonly used methods with LOR using air. Balloon indicators, LOR with lidocaine and an acoustic device were evaluated together in this group. As a group, these methods reduced three outcomes; the quality of evidence was moderate (Carvalho 2017):

  • failure to identify the space: RR 0.29 (high between-study heterogeneity)
  • unintentional intravascular or subarachnoid catheter placement: RR 0.35
  • unblocked segment: RR 0.37

These results come from a pooled analysis of different methods. The article's abstract does not report a separate result for balloon indicators, and products in this class have not been studied individually.

A randomized study included 80 surgical patients receiving lumbar epidurals. Median time to identify the space was 28 seconds with a balloon indicator and 90 seconds in the control group, which used LOR or the hanging drop technique. Needle control was also easier in the indicator group (Sawada 2012).

In a randomized study of labor epidurals comparing an epidural balloon with LOR using air (n=50), first-attempt success was achieved in 22 women in the balloon group and 14 in the air-LOR group. Procedure time was shorter with the balloon; accidental dural puncture and block failure were more frequent in the air-LOR group (Fyneface-Ogan 2008).

A randomized study of 240 patients undergoing cesarean delivery in Türkiye compared a balloon indicator, a spring-loaded LOR syringe and a conventional saline LOR syringe. The balloon indicator reached the space slightly faster than the spring-loaded syringe; the authors considered this difference clinically unimportant. Hesitation was more frequent with the balloon indicator than in the other two groups; the need for confirmation with LOR and failure were higher than with the spring-loaded syringe. The authors found the spring-loaded syringe superior in pregnant patients for endpoint clarity, ease of use and success (Kartal 2017).

With computerized pressure measurement, single-attempt success was reported in all 56 difficult obstetric cases after at least two failed attempts (Capogna 2018). A pain clinic series found a 10% false-negative rate: the tip was in the space, but the device did not indicate entry (Carassiti 2022). Another case series has also been published (Helf 2019).

Confirmation

How is catheter location confirmed?

Epidural stimulation testing and epidural pressure waveform analysis can help confirm that a catheter or needle is in the epidural space; neither reliably identifies intravascular placement (Pinho 2023). Ultrasound shows the level, midline and depth before the procedure; fluoroscopy with contrast shows spread in pain clinics.

  • Epidural stimulation test. A low current is delivered through the catheter and the muscle response is observed. A meta-analysis found 95% sensitivity; specificity could not be determined. The test requires a wire-reinforced catheter and a suitable nerve stimulator, is affected by local anesthetic, and does not reliably identify intravascular placement (Pinho 2023).
  • Epidural pressure waveform analysis. Pressure at the needle or catheter tip is monitored with a pressure transducer; a pulsatile waveform is seen when the tip is in the epidural space (Hong 2018). A meta-analysis found 90% sensitivity and 88% specificity. The method does not distinguish intravascular from intrathecal catheter placement; the authors report a high risk of bias (Pinho 2023).
  • Ultrasound. The level, midline and depth are marked before the procedure. In one study during labor, first-attempt success was 85.7% with ultrasound and 59.5% with palpation (Bae 2023); another study reported rates of 67.27% and 40% (Nassar 2015).
  • Fluoroscopy and contrast. Contrast spread is visualized; this is used for epidural steroid injection in pain clinics. In a study of cervical epidural steroid injection, LOR produced a 29.5% false-positive rate (Hong 2018).

Summary

Methods compared: how does each work?

The table brings together each method's operating principle, setting of use and evidence notes.

Comparison of methods for identifying and confirming the epidural space
MethodHow it worksUseEvidence note
Loss of resistance with salineThe plunger is pressed; resistance is lost when the tip enters the spaceCommon; the most frequent form in the United Kingdom obstetric survey (Howell 1998)52.7% used saline alone in the United Kingdom survey (Howell 1998)
Loss of resistance with airSame principle, with air in the syringeCommon; 59.2% in the Spanish survey (Figueredo 2005)No difference in success or complications versus saline; low-certainty evidence (Antibas 2014)
Saline with an air bubbleCompression of the bubble indicates resistanceUncommon; 6% in the Spanish survey (Figueredo 2005)
Hanging dropThe drop at the hub is drawn in by negative pressureThoracic, sitting position; some cervical proceduresAll thoracic pressures were negative in the sitting position (Gil 2008); not considered suitable for cervical use (Moon 2010)
Running dripSaline flows from an open set when the space is enteredUncommon; also studied in veterinary medicine (Martinez-Taboada 2017)
Balloon indicatorThe inflated balloon deflates on entry into the spaceStudied in labor, cesarean and surgical epidurals (Fyneface-Ogan 2008; Kartal 2017; Sawada 2012)In a meta-analysis pooling different methods, the group reduced failure to identify the space versus LOR with air (RR 0.29; moderate-quality evidence) (Carvalho 2017). In cesarean delivery, hesitation and failure were more frequent than with the spring-loaded LOR syringe (Kartal 2017)
Spring-loaded LOR syringeA spring applies continuous pressure to the plunger; it advances in the spaceStudied in cesarean delivery (Kartal 2017)In obstetric patients, found superior to the balloon indicator for clarity, ease of use and success (Kartal 2017)
Computerized pressure measurementPressure at the needle tip is displayed and signalled audiblyDifficult cases, training, pain clinics (Capogna 2018; Carassiti 2022)Single-attempt success in difficult obstetric cases (Capogna 2018); 10% false negatives in a pain clinic series (Carassiti 2022)
Epidural stimulation testLow current is delivered through the catheter and muscle response is observedConfirming catheter locationSensitivity 95%, specificity undetermined; does not reliably identify intravascular placement (Pinho 2023)
Epidural pressure waveform analysisTip pressure is monitored; a pulsatile waveform is seen in the space (Hong 2018)Confirming needle or catheter locationSensitivity 90%, specificity 88%; does not distinguish intravascular from intrathecal placement; high risk of bias (Pinho 2023)
UltrasoundLevel, midline and depth are marked before the procedureStudied for labor analgesia (Bae 2023; Nassar 2015)First-attempt success 85.7% versus 59.5% (Bae 2023); 67.27% versus 40% (Nassar 2015)
Fluoroscopy and contrastContrast spread is visualizedPain clinics, epidural steroid injectionLOR had a 29.5% false-positive rate in a cervical injection study (Hong 2018)

Frequently asked questions

What is the hanging drop technique in epidural anesthesia?

In the hanging drop technique, after withdrawing the stylet, a drop of saline is placed at the Tuohy needle hub and the needle is advanced slowly. When the tip enters the epidural space, pressure at the tip falls below atmospheric pressure and the drop is drawn into the needle; this indicates entry into the space. Alberto Gutiérrez described the technique in 1933 (Todorov 2014).

In which regions is the hanging drop technique useful?

In a thoracic study (T5-T6), all pressures measured in the sitting position were negative, while the median was +5 mmHg in the lateral decubitus position (Gil 2008). In the cervical region, pressure was not consistently negative and the technique was considered unsuitable (Moon 2010). In the lumbar region, no negative pressure was measured while the needle was stationary; epidural pressure increases as labor progresses (Todorov 2014).

Is there a difference between air and saline for loss of resistance?

The Cochrane review found no difference in success or complications between air and saline; the evidence was of low certainty (Antibas 2014). Both forms are common in surveys: 52.7% of Obstetric Anaesthetists' Association members in the United Kingdom used saline alone (Howell 1998), while 59.2% of respondents in Spain used LOR with air (Figueredo 2005).

What does the evidence say about newer methods such as balloon indicators?

A meta-analysis combining eight randomized studies (1,583 patients) assessed balloon indicators, LOR with lidocaine and an acoustic device together. As a group, compared with LOR using air, these methods reduced failure to identify the space (RR 0.29), unintentional intravascular or subarachnoid catheter placement (RR 0.35) and unblocked segments (RR 0.37); evidence quality was moderate (Carvalho 2017). In a cesarean study, hesitation, need for confirmation and failure were more frequent with the balloon indicator than with the spring-loaded syringe (Kartal 2017).

Does ultrasound make it easier to identify the epidural space?

In two studies during labor, first-attempt success was higher with ultrasound: one reported 85.7% versus 59.5% (Bae 2023), and the other 67.27% versus 40% (Nassar 2015). Ultrasound is used to mark the level, midline and depth before the procedure. Epidural stimulation testing, pressure waveform analysis or fluoroscopy can help confirm catheter location; the first two do not reliably identify intravascular placement (Pinho 2023).

About this article

This content is intended to inform healthcare professionals. Its application and clinical decisions remain the physician's responsibility.

Prepared by the Melekırmak Knowledge Centre. It is based on published studies; references are listed below.

Published:
Last updated:

References

  1. Waurick K, Waurick R. Epiduralanästhesie: Geschichte und Technik der Epiduralanästhesie. Anästhesiol Intensivmed Notfallmed Schmerzther. 2015;50(7-8):476-83. doi.org/10.1055/s-0041-100845
  2. Todorov L, VadeBoncouer T. Etiology and use of the "hanging drop" technique: a review. Pain Res Treat. 2014;2014:146750. doi.org/10.1155/2014/146750
  3. Gil NS, Lee JH, Yoon SZ et al. Comparison of thoracic epidural pressure in the sitting and lateral decubitus positions. Anesthesiology. 2008;109(1):67-71. doi.org/10.1097/ALN.0b013e31817b80df
  4. Moon JY, Lee PB, Nahm FS, Kim YC, Choi JB. Cervical epidural pressure measurement: comparison in the prone and sitting positions. Anesthesiology. 2010;113(3):666-71. doi.org/10.1097/ALN.0b013e3181e898e8
  5. Fukushige T, Sano T, Niiyama S, Muteki T. Study of the mechanisms of epidural puncture pressure. Journal of Japan Society of Pain Clinicians. 1995;2(3):399-404. doi.org/10.11321/jjspc1994.2.399
  6. Figueredo E, Blanque R, García Villalba FJ, De Andrés J. Identificación del espacio epidural: práctica habitual entre anestesiólogos españoles. Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim. 2005;52(9):521-8. PMID 16363296. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16363296/
  7. Howell TK, Prosser DP, Harmer M. A change in resistance? A survey of epidural practice amongst obstetric anaesthetists. Anaesthesia. 1998;53(3):238-43. doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2044.1998.00299.x
  8. Antibas PL, do Nascimento Junior P, Braz LG et al. Air versus saline in the loss of resistance technique for identification of the epidural space. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014;(7):CD008938. doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD008938.pub2
  9. Carvalho LP, Agarwal A, Kashiwagi FT et al. Commonly-used versus less commonly-used methods in the loss of resistance technique for identification of the epidural space: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. J Clin Anesth. 2017;38:41-51. doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinane.2017.01.017
  10. Sawada A, Kii N, Yoshikawa Y, Yamakage M. Epidrum: a new device to identify the epidural space with an epidural Tuohy needle. J Anesth. 2012;26(2):292-5 (online 2011). doi.org/10.1007/s00540-011-1278-1
  11. Fyneface-Ogan S, Mato CN. A clinical experience with epidural balloon in the localisation of the epidural space in labouring parturients. Niger Q J Hosp Med. 2008;18(3):166-9. doi.org/10.4314/nqjhm.v18i3.45021
  12. Kartal S, Kösem B, Kılınç H et al. Comparison of Epidrum, Epi-Jet, and loss of resistance syringe techniques for identifying the epidural space in obstetric patients. Niger J Clin Pract. 2017;20(8):992-7. doi.org/10.4103/1119-3077.214366
  13. Capogna G, Camorcia M, Coccoluto A et al. Experimental validation of the CompuFlo epidural controlled system to identify the epidural space and its clinical use in difficult obstetric cases. Int J Obstet Anesth. 2018;36:28-33. doi.org/10.1016/j.ijoa.2018.04.008
  14. Carassiti M, Pascarella G, Strumia A et al. Pressure monitoring devices may undetect epidural space: a report on the use of Compuflo system for epidural injection. J Clin Monit Comput. 2022;36(1):283-6 (letter; online 2021). doi.org/10.1007/s10877-021-00732-x
  15. Helf A, Schlesinger T, Roewer N, Kranke P. Identifikation des Epiduralraums mithilfe einer Druckkurvenanalyse (CompuFlo-Technologie): eine Fallserie. Anaesthesist. 2019;68(10):689-94. doi.org/10.1007/s00101-019-00671-y
  16. Pinho JM, Coelho DA. Confirming identification of the epidural space: a systematic review of electric stimulation, pressure waveform analysis, and ultrasound and a meta-analysis of diagnostic accuracy in acute pain. J Clin Monit Comput. 2023;37(6):1593-605. doi.org/10.1007/s10877-023-01056-8
  17. Hong JH, Jung SW. Analysis of epidural waveform for cervical epidural steroid injections confirmed with fluoroscopy. Medicine (Baltimore). 2018;97(13):e0202. doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000010202
  18. Bae J, Kim Y, Yoo S et al. Handheld ultrasound-assisted versus palpation-guided combined spinal-epidural for labor analgesia: a randomized controlled trial. Sci Rep. 2023;13:23009. doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-50407-7
  19. Nassar M, Abdelazim IA. Pre-puncture ultrasound guided epidural insertion before vaginal delivery. J Clin Monit Comput. 2015;29(5):573-7 (online 2014). doi.org/10.1007/s10877-014-9634-y
  20. Martinez-Taboada F, Redondo JI. Comparison of the hanging-drop technique and running-drip method for identifying the epidural space in dogs. Vet Anaesth Analg. 2017;44(2):329-36. doi.org/10.1016/j.vaa.2016.03.002
  21. Oleas Vivar LE. Localización del espacio epidural mediante una variante del signo de Gutiérrez, Hospitales Vicente Corral Moscoso y José Carrasco Arteaga Cuenca, 2012. Tesis (Especialista en Anestesiología), Universidad de Cuenca; 2013. dspace.ucuenca.edu.ec/items/2ad7fa92-d3e3-486d-a100-f0b55f3f70fc

Back to Knowledge Centre